Resumen
The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of the ICDAS and the DIAGNOdent Pen in the diagnosis of occlusal caries lesions without cavitation, and for basing treatment decisions on the results obtained. Eighty permanent molar teeth that were healthy and non-cavitated or that had an initial occlusal lesion were evaluated. All teeth were investigated using DIAGNOdent Pen and ICDAS by four examiners. Histological evaluation of teeth was performed using stereomicroscopy by a histologist and different experienced dentist. For evaluation of the data, weighted kappa values (kw), sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV) and likelihood ratio (LR+) values of the tests were calculated. The diagnostic results obtained using the DIAGNOdent Pen were found to correlate better with the results obtained from histological sections than those obtained using ICDAS. When the treatment decisions of the observers depending on the results of ICDAS, and ICDAS and DIAGNOdent Pen combination were compared with the decisions made based on histological examinations, the decisions based on ICDAS and DIAGNOdent Pen combined (kw: 0.522) were more accurate than the ones based on ICDAS (kw: 0.415) alone. In conclution, professional experience is an effective factor in diagnosing occlusal caries lesions without cavitation with ICDAS and in making treatment decisions for them. DIAGNOdent Pen is sufficient in diagnosing occlusal caries lesions without cavitation.
Citas
Mejare I., Källestål C., Stenlund H., Johansson H. Caries Development from 11 to 22 Years of Age: A Prospective Radiographic StudyPrevalence and Distribution. Caries research. 1998; 32 (1): 10-6.
Mejàre I., Stenlund H., Zelezny-Holmlund C. Caries incidence and lesion progression from adolescence to young adulthood: a prospective 15-year cohort study in Sweden. Caries research. 2004; 38 (2): 130-41.
Lussi A. Comparison of different methods for the diagnosis of fissure caries without cavitation. Caries Research. 1993; 27 (5): 409-16.
Weerheijm K. Occlusal'hidden caries'. Dental update. 1997; 24 (5): 182-4.
Thomas M. F., Ricketts D. N., Wilson R. F. Occlusal caries diagnosis in molar teeth from bitewing and panoramic radiographs. Primary Dental Care. 2001; 8 (2): 63-9.
Lagerweij M., Ten Cate J. Remineralisation of enamel lesions with daily applications of a high-concentration fluoride gel and a fluoridated toothpaste: an in situ study. Caries research. 2002; 36 (4): 270-4.
Weerheijm K., Eggink C. The clinical diagnosis of occlusal caries: a problem. ASDC journal of dentistry for children. 1989; 56 (3): 196-200.
Bader J. D., Shugars D. A. A systematic review of the performance of a laser fluorescence device for detecting caries. The Journal of the American Dental Association. 2004; 135 (10): 1413-26.
Fontana M., Young D. A., Wolff M. S., Pitts N. B., Longbottom C. Defining dental caries for 2010 and beyond. Dental Clinics. 2010; 54 (3): 423-40.
Gomez J., editor Detection and diagnosis of the early caries lesion. BMC oral health; 2015: BioMed Central.
Braun A., Guiraud L. M. J. C., Frankenberger R. Histological validation of ICDAS II and radiological assessment of occlusal carious lesions in permanent teeth. Odontology. 2017; 105 (1): 46-53.
Ismail A. I. Clinical diagnosis of precavitated carious lesions. Community dentistry and oral epidemiology. 1997; 25 (1): 13-23.
Nyvad B., Baelum V. Nyvad criteria for caries lesion activity and severity assessment: a validated approach for clinical management and research. Caries research. 2018; 52 (5): 397-405.
Melo M., Pascual A., Camps I., del Campo Á., Ata-Ali J. Caries diagnosis using light fluorescence devices in comparison with traditional visual and tactile evaluation: A prospective study in 152 patients. Odontology. 2017; 105 (3): 283-90.
Ekstrand K. R., Gimenez T., Ferreira F. R., Mendes F. M., Braga M. M. The International Caries Detection and Assessment System-ICDAS: A Systematic Review. Caries research. 2018; 52 (5): 406-19.
Braga M., Oliveira L., Bonini G., Bönecker M., Mendes F. Feasibility of the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS-II) in epidemiological surveys and comparability with standard World Health Organization criteria. Caries research. 2009; 43 (4): 245-9.
Chu Ch., Chau A., Lo E. Current and future research in diagnostic criteria and evaluation of caries detection methods. Oral Health Prev Dent. 2013; 11 (2): 181-9.
Ismail A., Sohn W., Tellez M., Amaya A., Sen A., Hasson H., et al. The International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS): an integrated system for measuring dental caries. Community dentistry and oral epidemiology. 2007; 35 (3): 170-8.
Pitts N. " ICDAS"--an international system for caries detection and assessment being developed to facilitate caries epidemiology, research and appropriate clinical management. Community dental health. 2004; 21 (3): 193.
Pitts N., Stamm J. International Consensus Workshop on Caries Clinical Trials (ICW-CCT)-final consensus statements: agreeing where the evidence leads. Journal of dental research. 2004; 83 (1_suppl): 125-8.
Dikmen B. Icdas II criteria (international caries detection and assessment system). Journal of Istanbul University Faculty of Dentistry. 2015; 49 (3): 63.
Lussi A., Hibst R., Paulus R. DIAGNOdent: an optical method for caries detection. Journal of Dental Research. 2004; 83 (1_suppl): 80-3.
Steurer J., Fischer J. E., Bachmann L. M., Koller M., ter Riet G. Communicating accuracy of tests to general practitioners: a controlled study. Bmj. 2002; 324 (7341): 824-6.
Akobeng A. K. Understanding diagnostic tests 1: sensitivity, specificity and predictive values. Acta paediatrica. 2007; 96 (3): 338-41.
Landis J. R., Koch G. G. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. biometrics. 1977:159-74.
Attrill D., Ashley P. Diagnostics: Occlusal caries detection in primary teeth: a comparison of DIAGNOdent with conventional methods. British Dental Journal. 2001; 190 (8): 440.
Oancea R., Podariu A. C., Vasile L., Rosianu R., Folescu R. In vitro evaluation of laser fluorescence devices for caries detection through stereomicroscopic imaging. Rom J Morphol Embryol. 2013; 54 (2): 333-41.
Heinrich-Weltzien R., Weerheijm K. L., Kühnisch J., Oehme T., Stösser L. Clinical evaluation of visual, radiographic, and laser fluorescence methods for detection of occlusal caries. Journal of Dentistry for Children. 2002; 69 (2): 127-32.
Pinelli C., Serra M. C., Loffredo LdCM. Validity and reproducibility of a laser fluorescence system for detecting the activity of white-spot lesions on free smooth surfaces in vivo. Caries research. 2002; 36 (1): 19-24.
Kockanat A., Unal M. In vivo and in vitro comparison of ICDAS II, DIAGNOdent pen, CarieScan PRO and SoproLife camera for occlusal caries detection in primary molar teeth. European journal of paediatric dentistry: official journal of European Academy of Paediatric Dentistry. 2017; 18 (2): 99-104.
Bakhshandeh A., Ekstrand K., Qvist V. Measurement of histological and radiographic depth and width of occlusal caries lesions: a methodological study. Caries research. 2011; 45 (6): 547-55.
Iranzo-Cortés J. E., Terzic S., Almerich-Silla J. M. Diagnostic validity of ICDAS and DIAGNOdent combined: an in vitro study in pre-cavitated lesions. Lasers in medical science. 2017; 32 (3): 543-8.
Achilleos E.-E., Rahiotis C., Kakaboura A., Vougiouklakis G. Evaluation of a new fluorescence-based device in the detection of incipient occlusal caries lesions. Lasers in medical science. 2013; 28 (1): 193-201.
Shi X.-Q., Welander U., Angmar-Månsson B. Occlusal caries detection with KaVo DIAGNOdent and radiography: an in vitro comparison. Caries research. 2000; 34 (2): 151-8.
Hamishaki K. S., Chiniforush N., Monzavi A., Khazarazifard M. J. An in vivo comparison of two diagnostic methods in secondary caries detection. Journal of dentistry (Tehran, Iran). 2014; 11 (1): 17.
Jablonski-Momeni A., Stachniss V., Ricketts D., Heinzel-Gutenbrunner M., Pieper K. Reproducibility and accuracy of the ICDAS-II for detection of occlusal caries in vitro. Caries research. 2008; 42 (2): 79-87.
Ari T., Kofman S. H., Ari N. In vitro evaluation of magnification and LED illumination for detection of occlusal caries in primary and permanent molars using ICDAS Criteria. Dentistry Journal. 2013;1 (3): 19-30.
Angnes V., Angnes G., Batisttella M., Grande R., Loguercio A., Reis A. Clinical effectiveness of laser fluorescence, visual inspection and radiography in the detection of occlusal caries. Caries Research. 2005; 39 (6): 490-5.
Kouchaji C. Comparison between a laser fluorescence device and visual examination in the detection of occlusal caries in children. The Saudi dental journal. 2012; 24 (3-4): 169-74.
Castilho L. S., Cotta F., Bueno A. C., Moreira A. N., Ferreira E. F., Magalhães C. S. Validation of DIAGNOdent laser fluorescence and the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS) in diagnosis of occlusal caries in permanent teeth: an in vivo study. European journal of oral sciences. 2016; 124 (2): 188-94.
Rodrigues J., Hug I., Diniz M., Lussi A. Performance of fluorescence methods, radiographic examination and ICDAS II on occlusal surfaces in vitro. Caries research. 2008; 42 (4): 297-304.
Souza J., Boldieri T., Diniz M., Rodrigues J., Lussi A., Cordeiro RdCL. Traditional and novel methods for occlusal caries detection: performance on primary teeth. Lasers in medical science. 2013; 28 (1): 287-95.
Chu C., Lo E., You D. Clinical diagnosis of fissure caries with conventional and laser-induced fluorescence techniques. Lasers in medical science. 2010; 25 (3): 355-62.
Aktan A. M., Cebe M. A., Çiftçi M. E., Karaarslan E. Ş. A novel LED-based device for occlusal caries detection. Lasers in medical science. 2012; 27 (6): 1157-63.
Makhija S. K., Robinson M. E., Bader J. D., Shugars D. A., Litaker M. S., Im H. R., et al. Dentists’ decision strategies for suspicious occlusal caries lesions in a National Dental PBRN study. Journal of dentistry. 2017.
Schulte A. G., Pitts N. B., Huysmans M., Splieth C., Buchalla W. European Core Curriculum in Cariology for undergraduate dental students. Caries research. 2011; 45 (4): 336-45.
Lussi A. Validity of diagnostic and treatment decisions of fissure caries. Caries research. 1991; 25 (4): 296-303.
Ando M., Eckert G., Zero D. Preliminary study to establish a relationship between tactile sensation and surface roughness. Caries research. 2010; 44 (1): 24-8.
Kühnisch J., Dietz W., Stösser L., Hickel R., Heinrich-Weltzien R. Effects of dental probing on occlusal surfaces-a scanning electron microscopy evaluation. Caries research. 2007; 41 (1): 43-8.
Ekstrand K., Qvist V., Thylstrup A. Light microscope study of the effect of probing in occlusal surfaces. Caries research. 1987; 21 (4): 368-74.
Lussi A., Megert B., Longbottom C., Reich E., Francescut P. Clinical performance of a laser fluorescence device for detection of occlusal caries lesions. European Journal of Oral Sciences. 2001; 109 (1): 14-9.