Abstract
The Central American Court of Justice (CACJ) (1907-1918) was created with the goal of minimizing conflict between the five republics: El Salvador, Costa Rica, Guatemala, Nicaragua, and Honduras. The CACJ, however, has attracted scant scholarly attention. Nonetheless, the Court is academically significant and historically relevant. The CACJ was not only the world’s first supranational body to which states would suspend their sovereignty and submit all complaints, but also evidence that international organizations could facilitate state cooperation and create peace. Addressing the gap in the literature through extensive archival research, this study finds the following. First, the Court played an instrumental role in mediating regional peace and averting war between the republics. Second, it addressed controversial issues concerning state relations such as non-intervention, the law of the sea, and international treaty obligations. Third, due to the Court’s profound legal work, it still continues to have the potential to contribute to international law and institutions. Finally, although Washington played a significant role in the Court’s rise and demise, the Court demonstrates the ability of Latin American countries to address their own regional issues. As a result, the CACJ is a valuable underexplored subject that merits historical consideration.
References
American Journal of International Law. (1908a) Convention for the Establishment of a Central American Court of Justice 2, no. 1/2, Supplement: Official Documents (January - April), pp. 231-243.
American Journal of International Law. (1908b) The First Case Before the Central American Court of Justice 2, no. 4 (October, pp. 835-841.
American Journal of International Law. 1912. The Magdalena Bay Resolution 6, no. 4, October, pp. 937-939.
Arguello, L. P. (1986) La Corte de Justicia Centroamericana. Law Thesis, El Colegio de Abogados de Costa Rica, San José, Costa Rica.
Baker, G. W. (1966) The Wilson Administration and Nicaragua, 1913-1921. The Americas Vol 22, no. 4, April, pp. 339-376.
Barbosa- Miranda, F. J. (2010). Historia Militar de Nicaragua Antes del Siglo XV al XXI. Managua, Nicaragua: Hispamer.
Best, G. (1999). Peace Conferences and the Century of Total War: The 1899 Hague Conference and What Came after. International Affairs Vol. 75, No. 3 (July), pp. 619-634.
Bolívar Juárez, O. (2011) La Convención Matus-Pacheco y el Amojonamiento de la Frontera Terrestre entre Nicaragua y Costa Rica. Temas Nicaragüenses, No. 33 (January), pp. 75-85
Booth, J. A., C. J. Wade, and Walker, T. (2006) Understanding Central America. 4th ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Cabrera, M. E. (1916) Mensaje Del Presidente de la República de Guatemala a la Asamblea Nacional Legislativa al inaugurar ésta su sesiones el 1 de marzo, 1916. El Guatamelteco, March 1, 15.
Carranza Ernesto, M. (1908) No 1: Corte de Justicia Centroamerican. In Demanda Intentada por El Gobierno de Honduras, 1-15. San Salvador: Imprenta Meléndez.
Castro-Ramírez, M. (1918) Cinco años en la Corte de Justicia Centroamericana. San Jose, Costa Rica: Imprenta Lehmann.
Costa Rica v. Nicaragua. [1984] (2011) International Court of Justice.
De la Reza, G. A. (2013) A plataforma formativa do Congresso do Panamá (1810–1826): a conjectura Pan-americana revisitada. Revista Brasileira de Política Internacional, Vol. 56 no. 1, pp. 5-21.
Defensa Del Gobierno de Guatemala Ante de La Corte de Justicia Centro Americana de Cartago en el Asunto de Honduras. (1908) Guatemala: La Imprenta República.
Demanda Intentada por El Gobierno de Honduras. (1908) Salvador Rodriguez G. Senor don Ernesto Martín, Secretario de la Corte de Justicia Centroamericana, Cartago, 16-131. San Salvador: Imprenta Meléndez
Dieta Centro-Americana. (1889) Pacto De Union Provisional de los Estados de Centro America, 15 octubre. San Salvador, El Salvador: Sistema de la Integración Centroamericana.
El Pais. (1909) Llegada del Presidente Zelaya a Mejico [Mexico], December 30: 1-2.
Fernández-Retamar, R. (2006) Pensamiento de nuestra América: Autoreflexiones y prepuesto. Buenos Aires: CLACSO
Hudson, M. O. (1932) The Central American Court of Justice. American Journal of International Law 26, no. 4 (October), pp. 759-786.
Karnes, T. L. (1976) The Failure of Union: Central America 1824-1975. Revised Ed. Charlotte, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
Kirgis, F. L. (1996) Elihu Root, James Brown Scott and the Early Years of the ASIL. In “Are Institutions Doing their Job,” ed. John L. Hardgrove. Special issue, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 90 (March), pp.139-143.
Keohane, R. O. 2001. Between Vision and Reality: Variables in Latin American Foreign Policy. In Latin America in the New International System, ed. Joseph S. Tulchin and Ralph H. Espach, 207-214. Boulder CO.: Lynne Rienner.
Kissinger, H. (1995) Diplomacy. New York, NY: Touchstone.
LaFeber, W. (1993) The American Search for Opportunity, 1865-1913: Vol. 2. The Cambridge History of American Foreign Relations. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Longley, K. (2009). In the Eagle’s Shadow. 2nd ed. Wheeling, Ill: Harlan Davidson, Inc.
Loveman, B. (2010) No Higher Law: American Foreign Policy and the Western Hemisphere since 1776. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
Lynch, J. (1992) Caudillos in Spanish America: 1800-1850. New York: Oxford University Press.
Madriz, J. (1908) Voto del Magistrado por Nicaragua en la Corte de Justicia Centroamericano sobre el juicio promovido el Gobierno de Honduras contra los del Salvador y Guatemala. Managua, Nicaragua: Gobierno de Nicaragua.
Martínez-Moreno, A. (1957) La Conferencia de Washington de 1907 y la Corte de Justicia Centroamericana. San Salvador: Publicaciones del Ministro de Relaciones Exteriores. Ministerio de relaciones exteriores de El Salvador, Salvador and the United States. (1916) Trans. Nicolás Leiva (June). San Salvador, El Salvador: La Imprenta República.
Ministerio de relaciones exteriores de El Salvador, Salvador and the United States, 1916. (1916). Trans. Nicolás Leiva (June). San Salvador, El Salvador: La Imprenta República.
Nación [Argentina]. (1918) Crónica Americana, August 22, p. 8.
New York Times. (1917) Naval Base as a “Menace,” March 10, p. 4.
New York Times. (1918) Arbitration Court Closers Doors, March 17, p. 6.
New York Times. (1916) Our Treaty with Nicaragua, November 15, p. 10.
Pereira, J. D. (2012) “Industrial spaces and workers’ communities: the Portuguese case study and the European historiographical tradition.” Revista Brasileira de História 64: 15-32.
Peixoto, R. A. (2011) Then Come What May: For a redisscusion on the Panther Affair and on Rio Branco’s foreign policy. Revista Brasileira de Política Internacional, Vol. 54 no. 1, pp. 44-66.
Pérez Zeledón, P. (1887) Reply to the Argument of Nicaragua on the Question of Validity or Nullity of the Treaty of Limits April 15, 1858. Trans. J.I. Rodriquez. Costa Rica: National Printing Office.
Republic of Costa Rica against the Republic of Nicaragua. Before the Central American Court of Justice. (1916) Trans. Press of Gibson Bros, Inc. San José, Cost Rica: National Printing Office.
Republic of El Salvador v. The Republic of Nicaragua. Before the Central American Court of Justice: Opinion and Decision. (1917) Trans. Harry W. Van Dyke (March 19). San José, Costa Rica: Imprenta Costa Rica.
Reyes Guerra, A. (1917) Alegato verbal del Dr. Alonso Reyes Guerra como Abogado del Gobierno de El Salvador en la Vista del Juicio Promovido contra el Gobierno de Nicaragua. San Jose Costa Rica: Sociedad Editora Nacional (Imprenta Moderna).
Rodríguez González, S. (1917) El Golfo de Fonseca en el Derecho Público Centroamericano: La Doctrina Meléndez. San Salvador: Imprenta Nacional.
Salisbury, R. V. (1989) Anti-Imperialism and International Competition in Central America 1920-1929. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources Inc.
Scott, J. B. (1908) The Central American Peace Conference of 1907. American Journal of International Law 2, no. 1 (January), pp. 121-143.
Schoonover, T. D. (1991) The United States in Central America, 1869-1911. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Serrano, J. A. (1994) México y la fallida unificación de Centroamérica, 1916-1922. Revista de Historia, no. 3-4, pp. 32-43.
United States and Nicaragua: A survey of the Relations from 1909 to1932. (1932) U.S. Governmental Printing Office: Washington DC.
U.S. Department of State. (1908) Inauguration of The Court of Justice For Central America. Prepared by Elihu Root. File no. 6775/459, 215. FRUS Documents: Washington DC.
U.S. Department of State. (1917a) J.A. Utrecho to Lansing, The Minister of Foreign Affairs to the Secretary of State. Prepared by J.A. Utrecho, Managua, Nicaragua. File No. 817.812/322, 1104-1112. FRUS Documents: Washington, DC.
U.S. Department of State. (1917b) The Minister of Salvador to the Secretary of State. Prepared by R. Zaldivar, San Salvador, El Salvador. File No. 718.001/55, 31. FRUS Documents: Washington, DC.
U.S. Department of State. (1917c) The Salvadorean Minister of Foreign Relations to the Nicaraguan Minister of Foreign Relations. Prepared by R. Arrieta Rossi, San Salvador, El Salvador. File No. 718.001/55, 32-33. FRUS Documents: Washington, DC.
U.S. Department of State. (1918) To The Chargé in Costa Rica (Johnson) to The Secretary of State [telegram]. Prepared by Stewart Johnson, San José, Costa Rica. File No. 713.001/71. FRUS Documents: Washington, DC.
Walker, T. W. and Wade, C. J. (2011) Nicaragua: Living in the Shadow of the Eagle. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Zamora, A. R. (1995) Intereses Territoriales De Nicaragua: San Andrés,y Providencia, Cayos, Golfo de Fonseca, Río San Juan. Managua, Nicaragua: Fondo editorial de lo Jurídico.
Zelaya, J. S. (1907) The Revolution of Nicaragua and The United States. Madrid: Bernardo Rodríguez Printers.